
Welcome to Plathville Fans Critique Moriah Plath’s Music and Suggest New Talents
Fans of Welcome to Plathville are expressing their dissatisfaction with Moriah Plath’s music, calling for the show to feature other talented cast members instead. Interestingly, the suggestions have come from familiar faces within the Plath family.
Moriah Plath’s Passion for Music
Moriah Plath, a prominent star of Welcome to Plathville, is undeniably passionate about her music career. Season 6 has highlighted her journey, seemingly centered around her latest album. Through her songs, Moriah channels her emotions, particularly the heartbreak she experienced, which resonates deeply in her lyrics. While some viewers appreciate her artistry, others are perplexed by her ongoing pursuit of a music career. Recently, Moriah hinted at closing a chapter in her life, leaving fans curious about whether her next steps will involve more music.
Mixed Reviews on Moriah’s Musical Talent
Discussions on Reddit reveal a wave of criticism directed at Moriah’s music. One user questioned the financial success of her songs, asking, “How on earth did Moriah make money on her music?” Many commenters expressed skepticism about her earnings, with one posting, “She probably made about $3, and it’s all from streaming her own music.”

Another fan shared a humorous anecdote, noting how Moriah’s song “Circus” appeared in a playlist of “sad” music. They joked, “I can’t remember what mix I clicked on, but her song was the first on the list.” Another viewer quipped, “It came up under sad songs because it’s sad that someone would make a song so bad.” Comments ranged from light-hearted jabs to serious critiques, with one fan declaring, “I honestly thought her music was trash and would never listen to it unless it was on the show.”
Despite some positive remarks about her work, those who defended her faced heavy downvotes, and comparisons to Taylor Swift sparked debate, with one user admitting, “I secretly like ‘Circus.’”
A Call for Fresh Talent
In light of the mixed reviews for Moriah’s music, the original poster suggested that TLC should consider showcasing other Welcome to Plathville stars. Many viewers expressed a desire to hear more from Olivia Plath’s siblings, Nathan and Lydia Grace Meggs. Fans fondly recalled their performance at a Cabo bar in Season 5, before Lydia Grace moved away.
While some appreciate Nathan for his gentle nature, others are hesitant to support him due to his controversial political views. Despite this, both Nathan and Lydia Grace continue to pursue music outside the show. Nathan has shared numerous videos on Instagram featuring his guitar performances, while Lydia Grace has showcased her piano and fiddle skills, even celebrating National Classical Music Day on her social media.

Conclusion
As Welcome to Plathville continues, Moriah Plath’s music remains a topic of lively discussion among fans. With calls for fresh talent from the Plath family, viewers are eager to see how the show evolves and which musical journeys will be highlighted in future episodes.