Andi and Nigel: Still Together or Already Over? Fans Are Split Down the Middle

No breakup announcement. No joint statement. And yet, the 90 Day Fiancé: The Other Way fandom is treating Andi Jane and Nigel’s relationship status like the biggest unsolved case of Season 8.

Here is the strange truth: depending on which clues you trust, they are either still together on their own unusual terms, or already over. Both readings use the same evidence, which is why fans cannot stop arguing.

The Clues Everyone Is Arguing About

Andi, a Nashville musician, moved to Brisbane, Australia, to live with Nigel, a First Nations DJ and drummer. Their relationship was never conventional: they agreed to ethical non-monogamy while living on different continents, and that arrangement became the fault line of the season.

On screen came the flashpoints. Nigel planned a camping trip with another lover shortly before Andi’s move, an incident fans branded the “Camping Girl” controversy. He canceled it, but the trust damage was done. Later, a “hall pass” fight erupted when Andi learned a former hookup of Nigel’s had moved out of his home only days before her arrival.

Off screen, the trail gets messier. According to reports, a fan discovered an Andi Jane dating profile on Tinder and shared screenshots on Reddit. The bio reportedly said she was not ready for a serious relationship but hoped to find a life partner eventually. Andi has not publicly confirmed every detail, so it remains a reported discovery, not a verified fact. At the same time, Andi appears to be back in the United States sharing Nashville gig updates, and according to reports, she told fan pages she remains in an open relationship with Nigel. As of October 22, 2026, the two still followed each other.

Photo: TV Shows Ace — Andi, whose reported Nashville return is the clue both fan camps claim as proof.

Team Still Together: “This Is Literally Their Agreement”

Team Still Together has the simplest argument: an open relationship couple doing open relationship things is not a scandal. It is the deal they made. Nigel never hid his lifestyle; after his divorce he embraced ethical non-monogamy and has said he wants it permanently. So when this camp sees a reported dating profile, they shrug: in a non-monogamous relationship, that is not automatically evidence of a split.

They also point to the quiet signals: no breakup announced, Andi reportedly saying they remain in an open relationship, and the two still following each other. For this camp, the Nashville gigs prove only that a working musician went back to work where her career lives.

Team Split: “Nashville, Tinder, and Silence”

Team Split reads the same clues and sees a slow-motion goodbye. Their case starts with the season’s core mismatch: Andi expected living together to turn the relationship monogamous, while Nigel never promised that. Once that hope collided with reality in Australia, this camp argues, the move was doomed.

Then they stack the off-screen evidence: Nashville gigs instead of Brisbane life, a reported profile describing someone not ready to give her whole heart to anything right now, and no couple content to counter any of it.

Photo: TV Season & Spoilers — The airport reunion, when everything still looked simple. Fans now rewatch that moment and argue about when it changed.

What the Tell All Has to Settle

Both camps are stuck on one unanswered question: what did Andi and Nigel actually agree to after Australia? If they reset the rules, Nashville and dating apps could fit inside a working open relationship. If they never had that conversation, every clue looks like drift.

That is why the Tell All matters here. Viewers need straight answers: Are they still together, and under what rules? Was the reported Tinder profile real, and did Nigel know? Until then, the honest answer is one neither team wants to hear: not confirmed either way.

New episodes of 90 Day Fiancé: The Other Way air Sundays at 8 p.m. ET on TLC and stream on HBO Max. Now it is your turn: are you Team Still Together, believing this is exactly the open arrangement they signed up for, or Team Split, convinced Nashville and that reported profile tell the real story? Drop your verdict in the comments, and tell us which clue convinced you.