Fans Are Split After David Woolley’s Celebrity Crush Reveal Leaves Christine Saying ‘It’s Not Fun’

It was supposed to be a lighthearted couples’ game. Instead, one innocent card turned into the most talked-about Sister Wives moment of the week — and fans are firmly split down the middle.

In a preview of the Sunday, October 25 episode, Christine Brown Woolley and her husband David Woolley sit down to play Let’s Get Deep, a card game designed to get partners talking. One question about doing anything without worrying about the consequences quickly turned into a conversation about celebrity “hall passes” — and Christine’s honest reaction has viewers debating what it really says about their marriage.

The Card Game That Started It All

The question, according to reports, was simple: if you could do anything today without worrying about the consequences, what would you choose? Christine answered like many of us would — she said she would go on a trip, right now, on vacation.

David, however, heard the question very differently. He thought the card was asking which movie star you would want a pass to be with. When Christine asked him to answer it himself, he named actress Elizabeth Hurley.

“Oh, a hall pass. Wow,” Christine replied, realizing what her husband meant.

Why Christine Didn’t Laugh Along

Where David saw a joke, Christine saw something she simply does not enjoy. In her confessional, she admitted the whole concept was new to her — and not her idea of fun.

“This whole hall pass term, that’s new,” she said. “A hall pass is just a fun scenario, but it’s not fun to me. I don’t like that kind of thing.”

For many fans, that honesty was relatable: Christine refused to pretend a joke was funny when it was not. Other viewers thought she took a harmless hypothetical too seriously — and that divide is why the clip has blown up online.

The Twist Fans Didn’t See Coming

Just when it looked like the couple were on opposite sides of the debate, Christine delivered the twist. She admitted that she also finds Hurley attractive — and that the actress could be her hall pass too.

“I know. I think she looks fine. She might be my hall pass too,” she told David, according to reports of the preview. David joked that they would end up competing for the same person’s attention. Suddenly, an awkward conversation had turned into a shared joke — and proof that the couple’s taste in celebrities lines up perfectly.

The Polygamy Joke That Divided the Room

The moment took another turn when David compared the hypothetical to polygamy, joking that if they both liked Hurley, that would not be a hall pass at all — it would be “like polygamy.” Christine shut that idea down immediately.

That is where fan opinion fractured most. Some viewers, according to online coverage, called the exchange “cringe” and felt the joke landed badly given Christine’s history with Kody Brown. Others argued her instant shutdown proved she is no longer willing to live that life for anyone.

What This Says About Life After Kody

Strip away the card game, and this scene is about two people still learning how each other thinks. Christine ended her spiritual marriage to Kody in November 2021 and married David in October 2023, and season 21 has shown them working through that adjustment, including in couples therapy, according to reports.

Christine did not pretend to enjoy a joke she disliked, and David did not back down from his humor. In the end, they agreed on one thing: Elizabeth Hurley. Whether you found the scene funny or awkward, it showed a marriage where both people say what they actually think.

So now it is over to you: was David’s hall pass answer just harmless fun, or did Christine have every right to say it was not fun to her? And be honest — who is your celebrity hall pass? Tell us in the comments.