TLC’s hit reality series Unexpected has kept fans hooked for years with its raw and emotional look at teenage pregnancy, family struggles, and the ups and downs of young relationships. Over the seasons, several couples have stood out and become fan favorites—or, in some cases, fan villains. With casting for Season 7 already underway, many viewers are wondering: which of the show’s most memorable couples might make a return?
Lilly Bennett & Lawrence Bishop – The OG Couple Fans Grew Up With
Lilly has been part of Unexpected since the very beginning, appearing from Season 1 all the way to Season 6. Her journey from teen mom to fiancée has given fans one of the most complete storylines in the series. Together with Lawrence, Lilly brought humor, love, and realism to the show.
- Why they stood out: They’re the longest-running couple on the show, and fans have watched them mature into adulthood.
- Season 7 chances: Slim. Casting calls for the new season specifically target teens between 14 and 17 who are expecting. Since Lilly is now in her 20s and already planning a wedding, she doesn’t fit TLC’s new focus.
Jenna Ronan – The Drama Magnet
Jenna joined in Season 4 and quickly became one of the most talked-about cast members. From her rocky breakup with Aiden to moving on with new boyfriend JJ Della, Jenna’s life has been full of drama, heartbreak, and controversy.
- Why she stood out: Her outspoken personality and messy relationship history kept viewers glued to the screen.
- Season 7 chances: None. Jenna recently confirmed she’s not returning, saying she’s ready to move on from Unexpected.
Emersyn Potter & Mason Ramirez + Season 6’s New Couples
Emersyn and Mason made waves during their time on the show, but fans were disappointed when they didn’t return for Season 6. Instead, viewers met new faces like Emalee & Nate, Kayleigh & Graham, and Aniyah & Dakwon, who brought plenty of teenage drama and complicated family dynamics.
- Why they stood out: Their stories highlighted the emotional and financial struggles of teen parenthood, sparking lots of fan debates online.
- Season 7 chances: Very low. TLC’s latest casting call is looking for completely new couples of pregnant teens, suggesting a fresh slate for Season 7.
So, Who’s Coming Back?
Based on the casting announcements, Unexpected Season 7 will likely feature an all-new group of young couples. While fan favorites like Lilly and Jenna have defined the show in the past, it seems TLC is ready to reboot the series with brand-new storylines.
Still, if history has taught us anything, it’s that Unexpected thrives on surprises. While the focus will shift to younger couples, fans shouldn’t completely rule out cameo appearances or updates on past stars in special episodes.