1000-Lb Best Friends Returns, but Fans Are Divided on Season 3

1000-Lb Best Friends has returned to TLC for its third season, but not all fans are thrilled with the new direction the show is taking.

This season marks significant changes for the friend group, particularly with the departure of Tina Arnold, which has opened the door for new cast members. A new woman named Tina and a man named Scott have joined the original cast, connecting through their bariatric support group.

While the original Tina didn’t garner overwhelming popularity, some fans feel her exit hasn’t resolved the show’s issues. What are viewers saying about the latest episodes?

Fans Long for the Original Dynamic

In the most recent episode, the cast members ventured into speed dating, with Ashley and Scott enjoying their encounters, while Vannessa appeared to make a potential romantic connection. Although this segment showcased some fun, many fans found Season 3 lacking compared to its predecessors.

One disappointed viewer expressed their feelings on Reddit, stating, “The show feels disjointed. I wasn’t a fan of the original Tina, but her absence and the introduction of new characters make this feel different. I miss the camaraderie from the first two seasons, where the women uplifted each other on their weight loss journeys.”

The viewer noted that the new dynamics have left the show feeling more like a collection of individual stories rather than a cohesive group experience. “Now, it feels like we’re following five random people on separate journeys, with too many solo scenes and only occasional meet-ups,” they concluded.

Mixed Reactions from Reddit Users

Other Reddit users echoed these sentiments, noting that the show feels different this season. However, some found positive aspects to the changes:

• “I do like how Scott and Vannessa support each other.”
• “I prefer it without Tina. The new characters bring an interesting dynamic, especially watching Vannessa succeed post-surgery.”
• “I enjoy all the episodes, past and present. Life evolves, and so do shows. We have to adjust.”
• “I liked the most recent episode—it was fun to see them try speed dating, and it reminded me of the old feel when the original girls did the ice bath challenge. But I understand your concerns.”

As Season 3 unfolds, it remains to be seen how the new cast dynamics will impact viewer engagement and whether the series can recapture the magic of its earlier seasons.